Most American Catholics now believe Friday exists for three reasons: it precedes Saturday, it permits jeans at the office, and it is the night every restaurant develops a forty-five-minute wait. Impressive, considering the Church has tied Friday to the Passion of Christ for two thousand years.
So let us review what the Church actually teaches, since the Code of Canon Law is apparently kept in the same Vatican vault as the Ark of the Covenant. Canon 1249: "The divine law binds all the Christian faithful to do penance each in his or her own way." Not invites. Not suggests for traditionalists with Baronius missals and strong opinions about felt banners. Binds. Canon 1250 then names "every Friday of the whole year" as a penitential day. Every Friday. Not just the ones you remember before the ribeye arrives.
Canon 1253 lets bishops substitute other penances for meat abstinence, and in 1966 the American bishops did exactly that for Fridays outside Lent. They insisted Friday remained penitential, urged real self-denial, and gave "first place" to (wait for it) continuing to abstain from meat.
The Church said: "You may choose another penance, though we strongly recommend the old one."
American Catholics heard:
"FRIDAY PENANCE ABOLISHED. BACON NOW A SACRAMENTAL."
Not since Arius read the Gospel of John has a text been so creatively misunderstood.
Yes, technically you can substitute another penance. Someone always materializes from the mist like a canonical Batman to announce this. Correct. So what did you substitute?
Silence. Crickets. (Also permitted on Friday.)
Eventually the answer emerges: "contemplative prayer." Specifically, contemplating the substitution.
If you visited the sick, prayed a Rosary, skipped dessert, or gave real money to the poor, splendid. Those are penances. But if your alternative exists only as a theoretical possibility you learned from Catholic Answers in 2009, you don't have a penance. You have a loophole, and you've been living in it since the Johnson administration.
It's like your wife saying, "You don't have to do the dishes; you can vacuum instead," and forty years later the house looks like Pompeii. You were given a choice. "Neither" wasn't on the menu.
So here is my radical proposal. No committee, no listening session, no forty-seven-page USCCB document titled Journeying Together Toward a Renewed Understanding of Piscatorial Accompaniment.
Just eat the damn fish.
Salmon. Cod. Grouper. A drive-thru fish sandwich of questionable provenance. Yes, I know shrimp isn't a fish. This is not a marine-biology seminar. The cow gets Friday off.
Catholic tradition has at various points waved through muskrats, beavers, capybaras, alligators, and barnacle geese, on the theory that anything sufficiently damp counts. If New Orleans can declare the alligator a seafood, you can manage a tuna melt.
The genius of abstinence is that it's concrete. Friday arrives, you skip the meat, done. Better yet, it occasionally inconveniences you.
Good. That's the point. Penance that never inconveniences you has suffered a design failure. Modern man finds religious practices valuable right up until they interfere with something he wants. Fasting is wonderful if we remain full. Mortification is wonderful provided nothing is mortified. Abstinence is deeply meaningful unless Applebee's is running a BOGO on bacon cheeseburgers.
Christianity is not Peloton spirituality. You don't get credit for the bike just because your laundry is drying on it.
The fish requires no discernment. It requires tartar sauce and lemon. It just sits on the plate saying: It is Friday. Christ died today. You are Catholic. Remember. The Word became flesh, so the flesh participates in religion. Sometimes the stomach needs catechesis too, and frankly, mine has been skipping class.
Before anyone emails the chancery: Friday meat abstinence outside Lent does not bind American Catholics under pain of sin, and us routine mackeral snappers shouldn't audit everyone's order at Chili's. The guy with the steak may have done a legitimate penance. Possibly. Allegedly.
But "the Church permits another penance" and "therefore I will do none" are different sentences. The first is Catholic freedom. The second is spiritual laziness wearing Canon 1253 like a fake mustache [and twirling it like a cartoon villian].
Let Friday look different. Let your coworkers ask why you're skipping the cookout burgers. Let the waiter hear you ask whether the soup has meat in it, and let him sigh. Let your appetites learn, once a week, that they are not sovereign.
And some perspective. You are not facing lions in the Colosseum or storming Normandy. You're ordering the grouper. If that feels like unbearable religious oppression, that is compelling evidence you desperately need to eat the fish.
The Church gave us flexibility, not amnesia.
Christianity is not a lifestyle brand. It is the religion of the Cross. And once a week, your tiny little cross can come battered, fried, and served with a side of coleslaw
Eat the damn fish…